Potential rivals to Ebrahim Raisi, Ayatollah Khamenei’s favored choice, were barred from the June 18 election, and the remaining candidates do not present a serious challenge.
Candidates in Iran’s presidential elections have always been strictly vetted, and those deemed insufficiently loyal to the Islamic Revolution were disqualified. Within those limits, contenders held differing views on easing domestic restrictions or dealing with the West, and sometimes the victor was even a surprise.
Now even minor differences that give voters some semblance of a choice appear to have been erased.
The candidates in the election scheduled for June 18 either espouse deeply conservative positions aligned with those of the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, or are little known, with no voter base and no chance to win.
And one candidate in particular is leading: Ebrahim Raisi, the current judiciary chief, appointed by Mr. Khamenei, who has a long history of involvement in human rights abuses, and who lost in 2013 in a surprise victory by the outgoing president, Hassan Rouhani.
With no credible challenger, Mr. Raisi is expected to win this time. Any serious competition has been winnowed from the race. Even some members of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps, known for their strong hostility to any political dissent, described the election as anti-democratic.
The Guardian Council, a 12-person body responsible for approving candidates, disqualified anyone who might shift the vote against Mr. Raisi, who, as a prosecutor and as a judge, has overseen the executions of minors and dissidents.
On Thursday, Mr. Khamenei publicly endorsed the Guardian Council’s final decision. He said council members had conducted their duty and called on the public to “not listen to anyone saying it’s useless, don’t go to the election polls, we won’t go.”
Ebrahim Raisi, the current judiciary chief, is expected to win the race.Arash Khamooshi for The New York Times
The council’s decision and Mr. Khamenei’s endorsement of it have rattled political circles. The reformist party announced for the first time that it has no candidate in the race.
Analysts say Mr. Raisi’s presidency would finalize a plan years in the making for conservatives to consolidate power, take over all branches of the government, marginalize any reform faction and severely restrict the internal power fights within the Islamic Republic.
“Today we are witnessing an unabashed attack on any semblance of republican principles in favor of the absolute power of the supreme leader,” said Abbas Milani, director of Iranian studies at Stanford University.
The appearance of an engineered victory for Mr. Raisi, 60, has prompted louder and wider calls for an election boycott and increased voter apathy among ordinary Iranians. Polls predict a low turnout. The most recent survey conducted this week by the Student Polling Agency, ISPA, showed only 37 percent of voters want to cast ballots.
With Mr. Khamenei’s allies already in control of the Parliament and judiciary, the takeover of the presidency could reshape the current negotiations on how to revive the 2015 nuclear agreement.
President Donald Trump renounced the pact three years ago, in what he called a “maximum pressure” campaign to squeeze more concessions from Iran, but his policy appears to have only strengthened the hard-liners.
President Biden wants to seek a wider agreement with Iran that would constrain not only its nuclear program, but also its missile development and its involvement in conflicts around the region. But Mr. Raisi and his faction oppose making concessions to the West.
What particularly astonished political circles in Iran was the Guardian Council’s disqualification of prominent political figures such as Ali Larijani, a centrist conservative and former speaker of the Parliament, and the current vice president, Eshaq Jahangiri, considered a reformist most closely aligned with Mr. Rouhani.
Centrist conservative Ali Larijani, center, registering in Tehran.Arash Khamooshi for The New York Times
Mr. Larijani belongs to a very prominent political family, and was appointed by Mr. Khamenei to lead negotiations for a 25-year economic deal between Iran and China. Mr. Larijani was seen as a candidate who could attract reformist votes.
While a former president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, and a former government minister, Mostafa Tajzadeh, the leading reformist candidate, were also disqualified, their removal from the race came as little surprise. Mr. Ahmadinejad, who was once considered close to Mr. Khamenei, has increasingly taken the posture of an eccentric opposition figure. Mr. Tajzadeh, who was imprisoned for several years for his political activism, had called for a revision of the Constitution.
“This is an election coup,” Mr. Tajzadeh said on Wednesday in a virtual town hall he hosted on the Clubhouse communal chat site, attended by at least 12,000 Iranians. “We must all speak up and say people will not accept the legitimacy of the result. People will not participate in this theater.”
Mr. Ahmadinejad has also said he will not vote and has denounced the Guardian Council. “Why don’t you just take out the Republic altogether and say this regime is all ours and nobody has the right to even protest?” said Mr. Ahmadinejad in a live Instagram talk he hosted on Wednesday with an audience of thousands.
Even Mr. Raisi voiced some concern and said that he had lobbied with the Guardian Council to reinstate some of the candidates so that elections would be more competitive.
Officials registering presidential candidates in Tehran.Arash Khamooshi for The New York Times
The council has not made public its reasons for disqualifying candidates and has only said that it approved those deemed suitable to lead the country in the current circumstances.
In early May the council announced new eligibility requirements to narrow the race, excluding anyone who holds dual citizenship, is younger than 40 or older than 75, has a detention record or lacks governing experience.
Kian Abdullahi, the editor in chief of the Tasnim News Agency, affiliated with the Revolutionary Guards, criticized the Council’s final list of candidates on Twitter, a striking note of discord from a group that has long symbolized Iran’s power base.
He said candidates must be acceptable to the public and that “the people must decide.”
Elections in the Islamic Republic have never been considered democratic by Western definition. Government opponents cannot run, and the process of vetting candidates and counting ballots is not transparent. In 2009, the election result was widely seen as rigged and led to months of anti-government unrest.
But even so, in elections past candidates representing different factions and policies were on the ballot, and the victor was not a foregone conclusion — rivals campaigned and competed vigorously. The public was engaged. Celebrities and pop stars were even enlisted to endorse contenders.
The months leading to presidential elections in Iran typically brought a party-like atmosphere to cities where young people rallied in the streets at night carrying posters, chanting slogans and waving flags of their favorite candidate. The security apparatus tolerated these fleeting moments of open civic discourse, partly because they gave the appearance of a population that endorsed the Islamic Republic’s legitimacy and participated in its elections.
Former President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad addressing supporters in Tehran in May. Mr. Ahmadinejad, who was disqualified from running again, said he would not vote and slammed the Guardian Council.Arash Khamooshi for The New York Times
This time around, election fever appears extremely subdued — partly because of the pandemic but also from an underlying apathy. Tehran and most cities are quiet, campaign posters are scarce and rallies and town halls are held online. Iranians have struggled through a year of pandemic mismanagement, slow vaccine enrollment, a collapsing economy and social oppression.
“I don’t know anyone around me who is voting,” said Aliyar, a 44-year-old engineer who asked that his full name not to be used for fear of retribution. “Because it has proved over and over to us that nothing will change with us voting. It’s hopeless.”
Besides Mr. Raisi, the other candidates are Mohsen Rezaee, former commander in chief of the Revolutionary Guards; Abdolnasser Hemmati, the governor of Iran’s central bank; Mohsen Mehralizadeh, a former governor of Isfahan Province; Amirhossein Ghazizadeh-Hashemi, a hard-line lawmaker; Alireza Zakani, a former hard-line lawmaker; and Saeed Jalili, a hard-line conservative and former nuclear negotiator.
Mr. Raisi, Mr. Rezaee and Mr. Jalili have run unsuccessfully for the presidency before. The other candidates are not widely known.
Abdullah Momeni, a Tehran-based political activist aligned with the reform faction, said the final list showed that the hard-line conservatives had strengthened power.
The Islamic Republic, he said, had “displayed a total disregard for public opinion and it’s doing it without paying any cost and crushing all potential chances of dissent.”
Lucious Sutton disconnected the water line, the gas line, and the sewer line for the home he’d built on Bauer Place on the northwestern edge of Evanston. He and his brothers removed the appliances and the furniture. They secured the windows. Then he watched as men he didn’t know—maybe they worked for the city, maybe for a property developer—jacked up the wooden house, set it onto a truck, and drove it a mile-and-a-half to the neighborhood the city had deemed more suitable for Black families. A sheriff stood by.
It was May 1929, five months before the onset of the Great Depression. Evanston, just north of Chicago on the shore of Lake Michigan, even then thought itself the ideal American town, with fine homes, a university, and a certain class. The city’s population had grown by tens of thousands in a decade, so that by the time Lucious and his wife, Minerva, were removed from their property, 63,000 people lived there, almost 5,000 of them Black. Homebuilding was lucrative, and the rules of segregation—some coded, some official—were well established. A 1921 ordinance allowed the city to limit where Black residents could live by rezoning residential blocks into commercial ones; racial covenants kept them away from other neighborhoods. More
rules and restrictions were to come.
Bauer Place was prime real estate. It was near a new elementary school and lush woods, and at least one developer could imagine some grand brick homes in the area. “There was only one problem,” says Carlis Sutton, a grandson of Lucious and Minerva. “They were afraid that Whites would not pay that much for a house in such close proximity to Black people.” Carlis says his family had a deed to the property. Nonetheless, the developer gave Lucious a choice: We can tear down your house or move it to the Fifth Ward. The six other Black families on the block—the Thompsons, Fraziers, Logans, Smiths, Hunts, and Collinses—had to leave too. The developer demolished the homes of those who were renting and paid the $130 permit fee to transport the others. The families had no recourse, no city agency to appeal to, no hope that the matter could be sorted out in the courts quickly or at all.
Permit to move Lucious Sutton’s house.
Courtesy: Evanston History Center
During that decade about 300 other families were also required to move their homes. The permits didn’t list the owners’ race, and it wasn’t the reason for every relocation, says Morris Robinson, founder of the Shorefront Legacy Center, which studies the history of the local Black community. When Black homes were moved, though, it was to the Fifth Ward. Among them was the home where Carlis now lives.
The losses for the Suttons began to accumulate soon after they settled in the Fifth Ward. Their new neighborhood was bounded by a sanitary canal to the west and north, train tracks to the east. The lots were smaller than those on Bauer Place. Not all the streets were paved; not every new resident had running water at first. Newspapers called the area “undesirable.”
Sutton says his grandfather had come from Tennessee in his teens and by the 1920s owned a successful plastering business. He had three employees and two cars. But after the family had to relocate, he started drinking and gambling and cheating on his wife. “To be disgraced like that in front of your family was a hard thing for him,” Sutton says. “It was emasculating.” The Depression made everyone’s life more difficult. Minerva divorced Lucious, took a job as a live-in maid for a White family in the nearby town of Wilmette and had to send her sons to stay with relatives. Sutton thinks about that loss of stability, the economic precarity that followed, the narrowing prospects for his own father, and the impossibility of a full accounting. And he thinks about 2931 Bauer. It’s a parking lot for a church, has been for years. Just to the side is an elm tree his grandparents planted. “If the house still sat where my grandfather put it, it would be worth $500,000,” he says. Sitting where it does in the Fifth Ward, the house sold four years ago for $152,000.
Carlis Sutton
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
Sutton has been calculating his family’s losses in these specific, often painful ways because Evanston is the first city in the U.S. to attempt to redress such harm. It’s begun a $10 million, 10-year local reparations program to pay down its debt to Black residents, starting with housing. Sutton, a retired teacher and longtime activist, is one of four residents recently appointed to the City Council’s new reparations committee to help figure out the details.
Sutton’s great-grandfather had been eligible for the 40 acres and the mule that the federal government promised the formerly enslaved after the Civil War. Sutton’s grandfather was building his business when Callie House, a Black woman born into slavery, led the first national movement for reparations and was imprisoned for nearly a year. A century later, the pandemic has laid bare the country’s inequities, and the protests after the murder of George Floyd have started a racial reckoning. In April the U.S. House of Representatives agreed to discuss the possibility of establishing a commission to study
reparations, more than three decades after the proposal was first introduced. President Joe Biden called the resolution, H.R. 40, a good idea. But full reparations from the federal government—an apology for slavery and the harm done afterward, compensation in some form—probably won’t be coming anytime soon.
Cities across the country and the state of California are starting to make a case for local reparations. They would have to be more limited but could come sooner. Evanston is relatively small and relatively wealthy, with some 75,000 people living in eight square miles. About 16% of the city’s residents are Black, and some of the families, like the Suttons, have lived there for more than a hundred years. Evanston had set up an Equity and Empowerment Commission in 2018 and apologized for its history of discrimination. It’s not a surprise that it was the first to agree to pay reparations.
But Evanston’s ambitions have collided with the program’s particulars, especially since the City Council voted in late March to begin paying out the first $400,000 to a select few applicants in the coming months. Some Black residents wonder about the ways and the means. They worry about institutions that might benefit and people who won’t. They think the program is too modest. These reactions are probably inevitable. Restitution is complex and emotional, and at the local level it will never be enough. Sutton says he knows people have complaints and concerns and ideas of how to do better. He does too. He also says he’s encouraging residents to apply anyway.
Some of the residents eligible for the Illinois city’s reparations program. From left to right: Tosha Wilson, Colette Allen, Roger Allen, Joyce Hill, Steven Burns, Carlis Sutton, Jermey McCray, and Bennett Johnson. Allen is holding a photo of her mother, Eleanor, who was born in Evanston in 1927. The family had fled South Carolina after the lynching of Eleanor’s grandfather.
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
Robin Rue Simmons was born and raised in Evanston. She’s 45, fourth-generation, and has been a real estate broker, bookstore owner, and nonprofit executive. She started a construction company. Now she owns and manages affordable housing and commercial property in her hometown. In February 2019 she was representing the Fifth Ward on the City Council—one of nine aldermen, as they’re called—when she sent an email to the Equity and Empowerment Commission. The subject was reparations, but the subject line was “Black Equality Policy.” She wasn’t sure how receptive everyone would be otherwise. She began the message: “Because ‘reparations’ makes people uncomfortable.”
Robin Rue Simmons
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
She thanked the members—a mix of city officials and community advocates—for their work and said it was time to do more. “I’d like to pursue policy actions as radical as the racial policies and actions that got us to this point,” she wrote. Later, she pointed out that there was a $46,000 difference in median household income between Black and White Evanston. A 13-year difference in life expectancy. An achievement gap between Black and White high school students that couldn’t be explained by income differences alone.
She was right about the sensitivity around a certain word, at least initially. “A few people said, ‘Call it anything but reparations, and you have my full support,’ ” she says. But she wanted to have those uncomfortable conversations. “Let’s not call it anything else to make you feel better about your role in it or our inability to address it before now,” she says. “Let’s call it what it is.” That spring the commission put reparations on the agenda.
That June, the City Council passed a sweeping resolution calling for the end of structural racism and a commitment to racial equity. It didn’t say much about how, and it didn’t say anything about reparations. Then, on June 19—Juneteenth, the holiday commemorating the end of slavery—the House of Representatives held hearings on H.R. 40, the first such session in a decade. The writer Ta-Nehisi Coates, who’d brought the issue back to national attention in 2014 with his Atlantic magazine cover story “
The Case for Reparations,” argued that America had a chance “to say that a nation is both its credits and its debits.” The actor and activist Danny Glover said his great-grandmother had been enslaved, his grandparents had been sharecroppers, and national reparations was “a moral, democratic, and economic imperative.”
William Darity, a professor of public policy at Duke University who studies the economics of reparations, told the New York Times he’d never been more optimistic about the prospect of comprehensive reparations. Darity and others argue that reparations should, at the least, close the racial wealth gap, which has persisted for generations so that now White families typically are seven times wealthier than Black families. Reparations on that scale, hundreds of thousands of dollars for each eligible African American, would cost trillions of dollars for all. That can come only from the federal government.
Rue Simmons was thinking about what reparations could look like for a city. She saw the big promise of national reparations and the smaller possibilities of local redress, but she didn’t imagine a conflict between the two.
A Homeowners Loan Corp. map of Evanston from 1940, prepared for mortgage lenders. The Sutton family home was in the green-shaded area in the northwest. Green means an A grade—the safest place to lend. The Sutton house was moved in 1929 to the area shaded red, which was graded D. Getting fair mortgages there was difficult.
Source: Mapping Inequality: Redlining in New Deal America project
Evanston’s Equity and Empowerment Commission hosted two community meetings that July, hoping to hear from more Black residents about what they wanted. Lots of people came with lots of concerns about education gaps and health-care inequities and opportunity divides and housing discrimination. Especially housing, says Rue Simmons: “It was very clear that housing was the area of the most tremendous damage, that wealth had been stripped away from us by the city’s practices and policies.”
In the 1920s and 1930s, more than 1,400 homes were built in the part of town where the Suttons and other Black families had lived, and according to historian Andrew Wiese, none were sold to Black families. Real estate agents steered them away, and no banks would give them a mortgage anyway. By 1940, 84% of Evanston’s Black residents lived in the Fifth Ward, and the White residents, many of them immigrants, had mostly moved out. That year the Home Owners Loan Corp., a federal agency, created hundreds of city maps showing the risk to lenders of approving mortgages in different neighborhoods. On the agency’s map of Evanston, the community that included what was once Bauer Place was deemed homogeneous and desirable. It received an A, and on the map it was shaded green. The Fifth Ward was determined to have detrimental influences and an undesirable population. It got a grade of D and was shaded red. That made mortgages hard to come by. When Carlis Sutton’s grandmother wanted to buy a home for them all in the Fifth Ward in 1950, she had to ask her White employer to talk to the bank. (After they moved in, Carlis climbed to the roof and yelled, “My house! My house!”)
The home (center) Lucious Sutton built on Bauer Place, now in Evanston’s Fifth Ward.
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
If someone couldn’t get a mortgage, they might end up with a contract loan. They’d have to put down a lot of money for a house, then make monthly installments at high interest rates. They didn’t get the title until the house was completely paid for. They never got equity, and they could be evicted any time they missed a payment.
Rose Cannon’s family was ensnared in this system. Her mother was a maid and a cook; her father worked for the gas company. They moved into a big home just beyond the southern edge of the Fifth Ward in the early 1960s. When her mother began suffering health problems and couldn’t work as much, they had trouble making their payments. They didn’t get evicted, not exactly, but they had to move to a smaller home in the Fifth Ward. Cannon says the lender transferred the contract. Their monthly payments were smaller and manageable, but her parents were embarrassed. “It’s hard for me to talk about it, because I was kind of ashamed that my parents never had any power in any of the houses that they owned,” she says. “My mom was ashamed of it too.” In the late 1970s, when Cannon worked for the federal government and her husband was a teacher, they managed to turn her parents’ contract loan into a mortgage. It wasn’t easy, she says. “It’s like we were in slavery and the master decided to release us.”
Rose Cannon
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
Stories like these, plus research commissioned by the city detailing its role in housing discrimination, helped clarify matters. Evanston would offer reparations for these injustices first. They were egregious, their damage was lasting, and the city was responsible. Now the city needed the money to pay for it. This is where the broad conversation about reparations comes up hard against reality. In this respect, Evanston got a little lucky. Or so it seemed.
Illinois was about to
legalize recreational marijuana. Cities would be able to collect a
local sales tax—new revenue, so far unclaimed in Evanston. Black people had been disproportionately hurt by prohibition; in Evanston, 71% of those arrested for selling weed were Black. Legalization was supposed to provide some measure of social justice. It made sense to the City Council to fund reparations with the tax money. The council estimated that the 3% sales tax would bring in about $1 million a year. They’d set aside the first $10 million for reparations.
Resolution 126-R-19 to create a reparations fund went before the council on Nov. 25, 2019. Who would be eligible? How would the money be distributed? What other debts did Evanston owe? The resolution didn’t say. The details would be worked out later. (The loose terms bothered one of the six White aldermen, Thomas Suffredin, and he was the only representative to vote no.) The moment was symbolic and historic, but in the drab council chambers, the reaction was subdued. The mayor at the time, Steve Hagerty, congratulated everyone, and then they carried on. “I remember just wanting to jump and scream and celebrate, and it was business as usual,” Rue Simmons says. About two weeks later, she did get to celebrate when Danny Glover and other reparations advocates came to Evanston for a town hall meeting. One of them, Ron Daniels, says: “It was one of the most powerful experiences I can remember in my lifetime.” Then it was back to work on all those details.
When Evanston’s only dispensary, Zen Leaf, began selling recreational pot at the start of 2020, there was a line down the street. During the pandemic, the state deemed dispensaries essential businesses, but the city wasn’t allowed to collect taxes until July. Rue Simmons and the two colleagues working with her on the reparations program decided to recommend starting with the $400,000 the council expected to have by year’s end. The idea had momentum, and they didn’t want to slow it. There were also local elections coming in the spring.
They settled on grants to help qualified Black residents buy homes, fix them up, or stay in them. Then they had to determine who was qualified. The priority is any Black resident of Evanston from 1919 to 1969, the year after the federal government passed the Fair Housing Act, then any of their direct descendants. And then anyone who moved to the city after that and can show that they’ve faced discrimination.
And the big question: How much? They decided on grants of $25,000—not a lot of money in Evanston, where the average home sells for many multiples of that. The $400,000 covers just 16 people to start with. That’s a tough number, another reality check. There are other restrictions: The residents won’t get the cash directly. The city says that would likely require them to pay state and federal taxes on it. Instead, the money will go to the financial institution providing a new mortgage or holding an existing one or to the closing agent handling a down payment. It could go to a contractor making repairs on the recipient’s home or to Cook County to pay property taxes. Rue Simmons says she and her colleagues want residents to be able to work with local Black-owned businesses and banks that have a history of fair lending.
The council planned another crucial vote for late March, on whether to begin distributing that first $400,000 for what’s now called the Evanston Local Reparations Restorative Housing Program. Just a few weeks before, a group had emerged on Facebook called Evanston Rejects Racist Reparations. Until then, there had been some questions and concerns about the program, but no organized opposition. The founders are Black residents of Evanston. Cannon is one of them. The group wanted the council to delay the start of the program until after the election. They said the program was too small. It shouldn’t require recipients to work with banks and other financial institutions that have discriminated against Black residents. It shouldn’t even be called reparations.
At the March 22 City Council meeting,
held virtually, so many people had something to say that the mayor limited them to a minute each. The first speakers were the Duke professor Darity and Kirsten Mullen, co-authors of the 2020 book From Here to Equality: Reparations for Black Americans in the Twenty-First Century. Darity said the program would do little about the equity gap in housing. Mullen challenged the premise. “There are some admirable efforts by municipalities to atone for their own race-based policies,” Mullen said. “However, it is unfortunate when those acts of atonement are confused with reparations.”
Cannon said that because she now rents an apartment and at age 73 doesn’t want to take on a mortgage, she wouldn’t benefit, even though she’d qualify. “We want cash payments,” she said. “I want reparations like any Black person.” Kevin Brown, another founder of the Facebook group, said: “The city of Evanston should not willingly mislead our country. … We support the housing program, but we don’t support calling it reparations.”
Kevin Brown
Photographer: Lyndon French for Bloomberg Businessweek
Many others were eager for the program to begin. Kamm Howard, a reparations activist who’d been advising the city, compared the 16 Evanston families that would receive the grants to the nine students in Little Rock who integrated the schools there: “This can open the door for others.” Lots of residents said they were proud of their city, that the program was a good start, and a long time coming. Carlis Sutton was among them.
Cicely Fleming, one of the council’s three Black members, had already announced her decision to vote against the resolution. She supported the housing program but opposed calling it reparations. “I think reparations is somewhat of a sacred term,” she says. To her it means the big promise—the trillions, not these millions. “We take these crumbs and hope that we’re going to get more crumbs later, instead of just saying, ‘You know what? We deserve a whole piece of cake.’ ”
The measure to begin the program passed, with Suffredin in favor and only Fleming against it. The vote was one of Rue Simmons’s last; she’d decided not to seek reelection so she could work as a full-time advocate for local reparations and H.R. 40.
A month afterward, enthusiasm for the program had grown, and some critiques had sharpened. New groups were forming. The council had established its reparations committee, comprising four community members, Rue Simmons and Sutton among them, and three of the four Black aldermen now in office. It will administer the program. An independent community group, the Reparations Stakeholder Authority of Evanston, was coming together. Evanston’s Black residents were talking, planning, watching.
On a windy day in April, at the Dollop Coffee and Hoosier Mama Pie Company on the southern edge of Evanston, Brown describes how he arrived in the city in the 1980s to attend Northwestern University on a football scholarship, married a woman whose family had lived in the city for four generations, stayed, left, worked as a school administrator and policy consultant, and returned. In 2019 he was very publicly fired as Evanston’s community services manager over what he says was a misunderstanding. He also says he left in good standing with the Black community he served.
Brown says it wasn’t until earlier this year that some people realized the city was going ahead with reparations. There had been regular public meetings, opportunities to comment, but they’d almost all occurred while the city was locked down, people were struggling, and no one was socializing much.
Then there’s the $10 million. It had seemed a smart idea to use the marijuana sales tax to pay for reparations. It’s such a convenient, tidy model that other communities might copy it. That’s the problem, Brown says. “I kind of call it reparations on the cheap. There’s no pain involved. I think it would be a different dynamic if reparations became an element of the city budget—of the core city budget—and the city government was saying, ‘We’re going to allocate a hundred million dollars over this period of time to fund the reparations budget.’ ” The city’s annual budget, for reference, is about $300 million. “This is just not costing anyone anything. So they’re OK.”
Percy Berger, 72, a former banker and private equity investor and the owner of a home in Evanston’s Lake Shore Historical District, calls the $10 million inconsequential, arbitrary. A national reparations program would have to calculate African Americans’ economic losses: The lost wages from almost a century of forced labor after America’s independence; or the loss of land, the 40 acres and the mule promised to those formerly enslaved after emancipation. Plus interest. But how, Berger wants to know, were the losses calculated in Evanston? “No one looked at it systematically,” he says. “And if they did and came up with that number it would be even more insulting.”
Outside the Fleetwood-Jourdain Community Center in the Fifth Ward, Herb Stevens says the housing grants are too restrictive. At the Church Street Barber Shop, Vicky Gaines says she’d prefer cash. Bennett Johnson, a 92-year-old local civil rights activist, would like the city to invest the $10 million and use the proceeds to set up community trust funds. Cannon, from Evanston Rejects Racist Reparations, would like an outside group, with no ties to Evanston, to administer the program; she says there’s too much mistrust of local leaders. Darity, the professor and author, continues to argue in op-eds and on Twitter that any local effort detracts and distracts from the struggle for full reparations.
This is an argument about what’s possible and what’s necessary and how far America will go. It’s happening in Evanston, and it will happen elsewhere. “Black folk have to raise their voices and say what reparations are,” Rue Simmons says. Some of the pushback she expected; some of it, she says, is personal and political. There will be plenty more discussion in Evanston about the remaining $9.6 million. The council’s resolution states it should be spent not only on housing but also on economic development and educational initiatives. Everyone hopes the $10 million is just a start and that 10 years won’t be the end.
That’s where the Reparations Stakeholder Authority comes in. Two of Rue Simmons’s informal advisers are helping set it up: Morris Robinson, whose Shorefront Legacy Center provided much of the documentation of
Evanston’s housing discrimination; and Michael Nabors, the pastor at Evanston’s Second Baptist Church and president of the local NAACP chapter. The group will raise money for reparations programs beyond the City Council’s scope and operate independently of it.
This summer, Black residents of Evanston will be able to apply for the $25,000 housing grants. The recipients will be picked randomly from among the eligible groups. Sutton says he’s decided to apply. He also hopes he can keep his position on the committee determining for the first time what local reparations will look like. If he’s one of the 16 chosen, he’d use the money to jack up his hundred-year-old house and replace the foundation.
Among the businesses shuttered by COVID public health orders last spring were gyms. The restrictions hit three Powell fitness centers hard, right as they were trying to get a foothold in town.
Club Dauntless owner Stacy Bair had opened the Lovell-based gym’s new Powell location in November 2019.
Jess Campbell, co-owner of Freedom Fitness, renovated the old Classic Lanes bowling alley on Clark Street to serve as a new centralized location. The day Freedom Fitness planned to reopen, the governor’s health orders went into effect.
Anytime Fitness’ owners spent months renovating the former Independent Order of Odd Fellows Hall, also on Clark Street. They were just about to open the business’s doors for the first time when the order came down.
Nationwide, the impact on the industry has been devastating. According to a fitness lobby group, the International Health, Racquet, and Sportsclub Association, 15% of gyms had permanently closed by last fall. Many of the larger brands had filed for bankruptcy, including Gold’s Gym and 24 Hour Fitness.
Keeping the community going
Despite the hardship the lockdowns caused, Powell was lucky that none of its gyms have closed their doors.
Campbell of Freedom Fitness said she didn’t wait until the governor gave the go-ahead to reopen. With all the anxiety and isolation during those early days of the pandemic, the emotional wellness of her members became a priority.
“We took the stance that, hey, we’re here to help people. We threw our doors open, we turned up the music, and we kept our community going,” Campbell said.
During the brief time they were closed, she had members renting out gym equipment, and she converted some classes into an online video format. She made that work for a while before she just reopened without permission.
“I said, ‘Enough’s enough. I’m going to make a living.’ I had gym members reaching out to me, for their mental health,” Campbell said.
The gym instituted some social distancing protocols when it reopened, and had a sterilization routine during those early days, when no one was sure if the virus was spreading through surface contact. Campbell said the cleaning requirements didn’t really inconvenience members, as they really weren’t out of the ordinary. “We have high-end standards for cleaning anyway,” Campbell said.
Since opening at the new downtown location, Campbell said, their memberships are more solid than ever. The gym offers a lot of youth programs, and being located near Powell Middle School and closer to Powell High School has made it easy for students to get to the gym. Freedom Fitness also has a lot of loyal members from its former location.
“My gym people are my gym people, and I love them to death,” Campbell said.
Prime Fit
Bair, of Club Dauntless, said there was some hesitancy in the early days when the gyms were allowed to reopen, but much of that has disappeared.
“It’s really behind us now. The energy in the gym is on high again,” Bair said.
The business started out in Lovell, and Powell residents regularly made the trip to Lovell to use those facilities. Club Dauntless has since opened locations in Powell and Greybull, and it’s going to have a new location in Cody as well.
Bair said the pandemic was hard, but it’s given people a perspective on the importance of health that they perhaps didn’t have before the virus swept across the globe.
“People in our community have a renewed appreciation for their health,” Bair said.
As the pandemic wanes, people are taking a look at other health risks, she explained, which is placing a priority on improving cardiovascular health.
“The feeling in the gym is better now than pre-COVID. People are excited to be able to go out and do something good for their health,” Bair said.
This is especially true of Club Dauntless’ senior members. The club has a program called Prime Fit, which caters to that population. Bair was worried that seniors’ participation would drop after the reopening; being in the highest risk group for developing complications from COVID, they might not be as comfortable returning to the gym. Fortunately, this wasn’t the case.
“That program is thriving,” Bair said. “We have more seniors in the gym than ever. Of all the things that Dauntless does, that’s the one thing that really grips at my heart.”
With things going well for fitness in Powell, she’s putting energy into the new facility in Cody. There aren’t a lot of details about the new facility as it’s still in the design phase. While the pandemic is becoming a thing of the past, there are new challenges to face with respect to construction materials, as prices have skyrocketed. Bair said the hike isn’t killing the plans, but it does make an opening date hard to pin down. The hope is that it’ll happen sometime this year.
Memberships at Club Dauntless are good at all locations, so when the Cody gym opens, it will offer one more option for members to stay fit.
Drunk Fruit, which highlights such Asian flavors at litchi, yuzu and melon, launched in late 2020.
On store shelves packed with more hard seltzer varieties than you’d ever want to sample, Drunk Fruit stands out. It’s not just the colorful, cartoony cans, so vibrant and appealing next to the generic white labels wrapped around the biggest-selling brands. It’s not just the flavors, which highlight yuzu and litchi instead of the yawn-inducing black cherry or grapefruit. And it’s not just that Drunk Fruit’s seltzers are seriously tasty — so tasty, in fact, that one of D.C.’s top chefs put them on his restaurant menus after Drunk Fruit’s founders slid into his DMs to ask if he’d be willing to try them.
When you add it all up, it’s easy to see why Drunk Fruit belongs in your picnic cooler this summer.
Drunk Fruit, which launched in late 2020 and is sold at 210 locations, including Total Wine and Whole Foods stores in Virginia and D.C., had its genesis during co-founder Kenn Miller’s 2019 honeymoon in Japan. After he returned, Miller told a group of college friends — all Asian American, all “really big fans of hard seltzer” — about the flavors he’d sampled abroad. As the group talked, says co-founder Steven Tang, “we thought we could do better” than mainstream seltzers they’d been drinking.
The branding and marketing of those seltzers “didn’t really speak to us and didn’t feel like it really represented us,” Tang says. Neither did the flavors: “We’re trying to take the flavors from the Asian grocery store and share them with the world. We know litchi, we know yuzu. We know how amazing these fruits are.”
Miller, who is half Japanese, says there’s a degree of nostalgia, too: Drunk Fruit’s Melon flavor is inspired by Melona, a honeydew melon-flavored frozen treat from South Korea.
Dorian Qi
Drunk Fruit was created by four college friends: From left to right, Steven Tang, Kenn Miller, Will Zeng and John Zhang.
Though their backgrounds are in tech and business, not fermentation, Miller, Tang and their friends William Zeng and John Zhang, all ages 31 to 33, went into start-up mode. Miller taught himself the basics of making hard seltzer by watching YouTube videos: “There was a lot of benchtop testing with the different flavor profiles, thinking about the different [fruit] extracts.” The early batches, Miller and Tang say, were not all successful — Miller describes some as having a “Captain Crunch smell and taste” — but they eventually improved enough to begin actual brewing of the seltzer at Beltway Brewing, a production facility in Sterling. (Recent batches of Drunk Fruit have been produced at Old Bust Head, a craft brewery in Vint Hill, Va.)
The three flavors show they’ve come a long way since those YouTube experiments. The Lychee is complex — sweet and tart, with notes of pear and white grape. Yuzu is very dry, with an appealing citrus sweetness falling somewhere between a lemon and orange, and just a hint of tartness. Melon is the sweetest of the three, full of kiwi and green Jolly Rancher, but dry and appealing, and reminiscent of melon soju highballs found at bars in Annandale. Like most other hard seltzers on the market, Drunk Fruit contains no sugar, is between 4.5 and 5 percent alcohol by volume, and is 100 calories per 12-ounce can.
Drunk Fruit’s founders were so confident in their product that in January, they sent an Instagram message to chef Danny Lee, whose projects include Mandu, Anju and Chiko, asking for a meeting. “I tasted them, and I thought it was really unique and fun,” says Lee, whose favorite was the Lychee. “It’s a really light, subtle flavor. You don’t get that artificial sweetness,” that’s so prevalent in other seltzers. He agreed to stock Drunk Fruit at all of his D.C. restaurants.
Lee says that some of his bartenders have experimented with creating low-ABV cocktails with Drunk Fruit, but mostly, they sell it by the can. “People think it’s really fun,” he says. “That’s the word we hear over and over again.”
Co-founder John Zhang drew the drunk fruit on the eye-catching labels.
“Fun” is the right word for Drunk Fruit’s eye-catching labels, which feature cheerful cartoon fruits — “very kawaii,” Tang says, using the Japanese word for “cute.” The mascots “were originally kind of an homage to some of the things you see in an Asian grocery store. A lot of the products imported from Japan and China have cute little mascots like this, and the idea was that these mascots bring a little bit of an Asian element and Asian look and feel to the packaging.”
Take a closer look at the fruit on the labels, and you’ll see they really are drunk: “You’ll notice they all are blushing a little bit, which is a little reference to the Asian glow meme that, you know, Asians get red when they drink,” Tang explains. “We’re kind of trying to be a little bit of tongue-in-cheek with these characters.” The fruit, drawn by co-founder Zhang, have become a key part of the brand’s identity; Yuzu, in particular, shows up on Drunk Fruit’s Instagram feed wearing costumes on Halloween, or appearing in “behind the scenes” photos from online video shoots.
Drunk Fruit officially launched last October in Northern Virginia and Los Angeles, which sounds like an odd geographical split, until you learn that Miller lives in Northern Virginia, near his family, and the other co-founders are based in L.A. In December, Total Wine began carrying the cans in its Virginia stores. More recently, they’ve been picked up by BevMo in Southern California, as well as Whole Foods in the Washington area. In the future, they’re planning to expand into Maryland and New York, as well as increase their distribution in California. (Also, Tang and Miller joke, they might start selling plushies of the fruit mascots, which some of the co-founders were pushing before the hard seltzer ever hit the market.)
More than anything else, Drunk Fruit is giving itself a niche in an overstuffed market. The founders say they’ll keep working with Asian American businesses — look for an event pairing Drunk Fruit and local bao favorites Bun’d Up coming later this summer — and showing that hard seltzer can be more diverse than #WhiteClawSummer would have you believe.
“Our whole mission is to bring people together through Asian American culture,” Miller says. “These flavors are really nostalgic to us, growing up, and we wanted to share a little slice of Asian culture through that lens.”
Toni L. Sandys
The Washington Post
Aslin’s first batch of Vibez hard seltzers featured such flavors as black cherry, lime and grapefruit.
Also buzz-worthy
Celebrities and national brands continue to launch new flavors of seltzer, but don’t overlook the hard seltzers made by craft breweries in our own backyard.
Aslin Vibez: Summer Nights
When Aslin dropped its first Vibez hard seltzer variety pack last June, the flavors were familiar to anyone who’d ever walked down a hard seltzer aisle: Black Cherry, Lime and Grapefruit. It was a surprisingly pedestrian turn from Aslin, a brewery known for creative IPAs with tropical-fruit aromas, and for aging stouts with bacon, cocoa nibs, coffee or marshmallow. “I think we were very shortsighted and tried to just match a gap in the market,” says co-founder Andrew Kelley. “We quickly realized that that gap really didn’t need to be filled, and we needed to identify where our place was.”
Subsequent releases of Vibez have had more of what Kelley calls “that Aslin flair,” including Pineapple Coconut and, last fall, Pumpkin Spice. The new Summer Vibez pack is a nostalgia trip for ’80s and ’90s kids. Blue Ice has the garish color of Fla-Vor-Ice and that sweet, fake raspberry taste of, well, anything “blue raspberry”: slushees, Gatorade, Nerds. (It can be a little cloying.) Tropical Punch is a dead-ringer for Hawaiian Punch. Sun Surfer? Think Smarties.
Later this summer, Kelley says Aslin will release Vibez Extra, its first “smoothie seltzers” — a richer, higher-alcohol style of seltzer, made with fruit puree, which is often closer to a canned cocktail than flavored carbonated water. Kelley also says Aslin will unveil “Vibez bars” in the brewery’s beer gardens, including Vibez cocktails made with the products.
Contains 12 16-ounce cans of Blue Ice, Sun Surfer and Tropical Punch. $18.99 from aslinbeer.com. Also available in stores.
Toni L. Sandys
The Washington Post
DC Brau’s Full Transparency Crush seltzers.
DC Brau Full Transparency Crush Variety Pack
DC Brau launched its first Full Transparency Hard Seltzer in November 2019, riding the tail-end of White Claw Summer. Co-founder Brandon Skall had started drinking hard seltzers as a lower-calorie alternative to beer and noticed more people buying them in stores. “I wanted to put our flag down early,” he says. “I thought, wouldn’t it be great if we brought the same sort of mentality that we brought to beer when we started DC Brau, making a local one, with an emphasis on flavor, to really do it the best that we could.”
As it turned out, that early start was essential to getting Brau through a tough year. “Historically, 60 percent of our revenue comes from sales at bars and restaurants,” Skall says. But on the other hand, “Seltzer is really a retail-oriented product. Ninety-nine percent of its production is in cans, sold in retail in variety packs.” At least 20 percent of all of DC Brau’s sales in the last year were seltzer, he notes.
Orange Crush, inspired by the popular Maryland-born beach cocktail, launched last summer, and in April, the brewery released “the Crush Variety Pack,” with Grapefruit Crush, Key Lime Pie Crush and Peach Melon Crush joining the lineup. Grapefruit is the star addition; the others veer toward the sweeter side of the spectrum.
Earlier this year, DC Brau partnered with Washington Nationals first-round pick Carter Kieboom on Kieboom Crush, a peach lemonade seltzer closer to an Arnold Palmer, with a bit of candy lemon. Kieboom might not be ready for the big leagues right now, but the seltzer has proved popular. Look for it when DC Brau unveils a beer garden in the parking lot behind its Woodridge brewery on June 11.
Contains 12 12-ounce cans of Orange Crush, Grapefruit Crush, Key Lime Pie Crush and Peach Melon Crush. $19.99 from dcbrau.com. Also available in stores.
Toni L. Sandys
The Washington Post
MoCo Hard Seltzer from Denizens Brewing Company.
Denizens MoCo Hard Seltzer
Denizens’ hard seltzer line is unabashedly local. Originally developed with the hyperlocal MoCo Show website, the cans of Blood Orange flavor read, “MoCo Goes Hard. This is Montgomery County’s hard seltzer.” It’s available at shops in Montgomery County, as well as in the brewery taprooms in Silver Spring and Riverdale Park (which is admittedly in Prince George’s County).
But MoCo’s branding might be holding it back: “Later in 2021, we plan to convert from the ‘MoCo’ moniker to a more generic one that will enable us to distribute throughout our distribution footprint in Northern Virginia, D.C. and Maryland,” Denizens co-founder Emily Bruno says in an email.
If that helps MoCo get in front of more customers, it’s a good move: MoCo’s flavors are drier than some of its competitors, but also more natural and more subtle. If you’re looking for a hard seltzer that could be confused for a can of LaCroix or Spindrift, reach for the Lime, or the light-bodied Blood Orange. Coconut overwhelms pineapple in the Piña Colada, but that also makes it an interesting mixer with your favorite rum.
Six-packs of Blood Orange, Lime, Pina Colada or Strawberry Cucumber (no mixed packs). $9.99 each from denizensbrewingco.com. Also available at retailers in Montgomery County.
READ MORE As D.C. reopens, why some venues are taking it slow, and you still might need a mask Two local breweries are making craft beer without the buzz How to garnish cocktails, now that you’re drinking with friends again
May 26, 2021 at 02:00PM
https://www.washingtonpost.com/goingoutguide/drunk-fruit-hard-seltzer/2021/05/26/b466e276-bca5-11eb-b26e-53663e6be6ff_story.html
Move over, White Claw. Drunk Fruit is the hard seltzer you should be drinking this summer. - Washington Post